Project Co-Sponsors:

Project Funders:

Home > Partitions Overview > Lessons Learnt

Lessons Learnt
 
A. Containing the Conflict
 
Region/ Country Policy Result
Balkans general Crisis by crisis management. Conflict continued and spread to other areas.
Croatia UN Protected Areas (UNPAS) in Serbian majority areas of Croatia with mandate to demilitarize them. Serbian Diaspora support from Bosnia prevented demilitarization.
Bosnia No mandate for UN troops stationed in Bosnia to prevent the spillover of conflict from Croatia
Safe havens for isolated Muslim enclaves.
Four years of war.




Srebrenica massacre.
Kosovo Negotiations for NATO protectorate in Kosovo through talks at Rambouillet NATO air war against Serbia.
Serbia The Kosovo Force (KFOR) to nip spillover of conflict to the Presevo valley of Serbia by creating a buffer zone along the Kosovo border with the valley. Presevo valley being reintegrated into Serbia
Macedonia NATO and KFOR cooperation to bring Albanian guerillas to lay down arms and negotiate peace. Peace agreement and partial demilitarization.
Lesson Learned Local crisis management only works when synchronized with regional crisis management.  

B. Peace-Making
 
Region/ Country Peace Agreement Result
Balkans general Conflict by conflict agreements based on the separation of forces. Mixed.
Croatia UN to demilitarize UN Protected Areas but no roadmap on reintegration. Forcible reintegration accompanied by ethnic cleansing.
Bosnia Two separate entities created under loose joint presidency with NATO led stabilization, UN police and partial international administration. Simmering peace, de facto partition, no exit in view.
Kosovo NATO protectorate, UN trusteeship, province's future status to be determined. Simmering peace, spillover of conflict to Macedonia.
Macedonia NATO supervised demilitarization of guerrillas, municipal devolution and Albanian minority rights. Partial demilitarization, progress on devolution and minority rights.
Lesson Learned Separation of forces agreements work to the extent they are combined with nation-building.  

C. Stabilization
 
Region/ Country International Involvement Result
Balkans general UN, NATO, EU, OSCE, International Financial Organizations, international aid agencies, refugee and migration agencies. Dissipation of responsibilities.
Bosnia NATO security force, UN, EU and international organizations to work with two entity governments on reconstruction and stabilization. Overall security but returning refugees attacked, weak economy, no reintegration.
Kosovo NATO security force, UN trusteeship (UNMIK) to build institutions for self-rule. Scant resources, no reintegration.
Macedonia OSCE led municipal training, NATO and EU aided police and border management. Too early to say.
Serbia U.S. and EU support for civil society and opposition parties, EU and OSCE municipal twinning programs. Mixed - democrats in power but powerful criminal elements still in security apparatus.
Lesson Learned Stability and economic recovery difficult without putting civil administration and rule of law on fast track.  

D. Nation-Building
 
Region/ country Programs Result
Bosnia OSCE supervised elections, basic infrastructure reconstruction, IMF and World Bank supervised transition to market economy, UN led task force to monitor local police, Council of Europe and The Hague supervised judicial reform. Nationalists' hold gradually weakened, criminal hold on economy and local security continued, corruption spread.
Kosovo UNMIK led Kosovar interim advisory council for constitution and elections, OSCE police training and municipal development. New provincial assembly barely functioning, nationalists still strong in police.
Macedonia Direct NATO and EU support and aid for existing government to reform security and minority rights provisions. Gradual implementation of reforms, return of social democrats.
Lesson Learned Focus on political nation building needs to go hand in hand with focus on administration, taking local capacity as baseline.  
Text written by Radha Kumar and David Pacheco.
Copyright, Radha Kumar, 2007.